Debt Payoff: Snowball vs Avalanche
Enter every balance once and run both ordering strategies side by side.
The two strategies
Both methods have you pay the minimum on everything and throw all spare cash at one target debt at a time. They differ only in which debt is the target. Snowball targets the smallest balance first, which produces a visible win early — the first debt disappears in months — and the psychological momentum is the entire point. Avalanche targets the highest interest rate first, which is mathematically optimal: every spare dollar removes the interest that costs you the most, so total interest paid is minimised.
How much the choice actually matters
The avalanche advantage is real but frequently oversold. When rates are clustered — say 5% to 9% across all debts — the two methods land within a few percent of each other in total interest, and the behavioural risk of abandoning a plan that produces no early wins is worth more than the difference. The gap widens dramatically when one debt carries a much higher rate, such as a 24% credit card sitting next to a 4% student loan. In that case avalanche saves thousands. Run your own numbers here and look at the actual difference rather than assuming.
How the simulation works
Each month: every open debt accrues balance × APR ÷ 12, every debt receives its minimum payment, and the entire spare amount goes to the target debt, which is recomputed each month by the chosen rule. When a debt is cleared, its minimum payment is freed and added to the spare amount for the following month — the "roll-up" that makes both strategies accelerate as they progress. The loop runs until every balance is zero or 600 months elapse, whichever comes first.
Why paying the minimum on everything matters
A common failure is throwing everything at one debt while letting another fall behind. Minimums exist to keep accounts current; missing one triggers late fees and, on many cards, a penalty rate that can push an APR above 29%, which destroys the arithmetic of any plan. Both strategies here pay every minimum first, and the spare amount is genuinely spare — defined as what remains after minimums, not before them.
Reading the result
- Difference in interest is the headline. If it is small, choose snowball for the momentum.
- Time to the first win is the hidden variable. If avalanche means nine months before anything closes, and you know you quit things at month four, the cheaper plan is worthless.
- Total months is often identical or near-identical between the two, because both concentrate the same total cash flow.